Page 1 of 1

Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Tue Sep 22, 2015 8:01 pm
by Marek Sk
It has been a while since I have been looking for Crimson Anemones and trying to see if there is a shy tiny critter that is almost only found together with Crimson Anemones.

Andy Lamb in his book ""Marine Life of the Pacific North West" Says: ""Nearly always associated with the crimson anemone the candy stripe shrimp is a favourite of the underwater photographer. However, getting the shot requires stealth and patience. Good luck!"

Part of the problem was that I was always looking at the top of Crimson Anemone but actually all 3 shrimps /eualids are found at the bottom, near by or underneath the anemone arm. See the pictures below.

What I found interesting that there are also much smaller Kincaid's Shrimp and Shortscale Eualid (or Threespine Shrimp).

Shortscale Eualid which look a bit similar to candy stripe but do not have blue rings they can be found all over Puget Sound.
Andy Lamb does not mention any link to Crimson Anemone but there is another resource from our Well Recognised & Appreciated Member of NWDC:
Greg Jensen in his book "Crabs and Shrimp of the Pacific Coast". Greg writes:"Under Shortscale Eualid:"Juveniles can sometimes be found clinging to columns of large plumose anemones and also around Crimson Anemones"

It has been a while since I first discussed Candy Stripe Shrimp with another Underwater photographer - Drew Collins.
It was he who first pointed out to me that in order to identify Candy Stripe you have to verify it has blue rings.
I had many photographs as far as Titlow but Drew told me that both Crimson Anemones & Candy stripe Shrimps mostly reside northern Puget Sound and over 100s of dives in Edmonds Underwater Park he found there one only once.

Eric "Yellow Eye" mention about the book "The Salish Sea: Jewel of the Pacific Northwest". Drew Collins was a major contributor to this book.
You can find more about him from his website: http://www.photographyunderwater.net

Andy Lamb in his book ""Marine Life of the Pacific North West" Says: " Kincaid's shrimp: Though very often associated with the crimson anemone and in considerable numbers, Kincaid's shrimp is not always readily noticed. The white mid-rib along the pointed extension between the eyes or nostrum is distinctive"

{Update added 9/23/15}
It looks like there is also another Shrimp that may look like Shortscale Eualid but is bigger. It is Threespine Shrimp.
Greg writes in his book: "Habitat: Common subtidally in Puget Sound in a wide range of habitats.

If you want to see more Critters I found at Anacortes Skyline Marina Wall yesterday, you can go to:
"Moved from Whidbey Island Critters - in footsteps of Jan K"

http://www.nwdiveclub.com/viewtopic.php ... 78#p269278

Here are the pictures of Candy Stripe Shrimp, Kincaid's Shrimp and Shortscale Eualid:

Please click on any picture if you want to enlarge.

Zoomed in:
PICT6780-candy-stripe-shrimp-zoom-mod.jpg
PICT8897-candy-stripe-shrimp-zoom.jpg
PICT8891-candy-stripe-shrimp-zoom.jpg
Original:
PICT6778-candy-stripe-shrimp.JPG
PICT6779-candy-stripe-shrimp.JPG
PICT6780-candy-stripe-shrimp.JPG
PICT8891-candy-stripe-shrimp.JPG
PICT8897-candy-stripe-shrimp.JPG
Here are the pictures of Crimson Anemones and their Surrounding Environment:
PICT6748-crimson-anemone-surrounding-cucumbers-closer.JPG
PICT6750-crimson-anemone-surrounding-cucumbers-closer.JPG
PICT6751-crimson-anemone-surrounding-cucumbers-closer.JPG
PICT6762-crimson-anemone-surrounding-cucumbers-closer.JPG
PICT6784-crimson-anemone-inside.JPG
PICT6791-crimson-anemone.JPG
PICT6747-crimson-anemone-surrounding-cucumbers.JPG
PICT6811-crimson-anemone-surrounding-area.JPG

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Tue Sep 22, 2015 9:26 pm
by YellowEye
Hi
I haven't heard of Shortcase Eualids. But yes, Kincaid shrimp are almost always nearby. Usually in larger numbers than candy stripes. I believe I read in the Salish Sea book that the Kincaid's eat the Snakelock Anemone, and the Candy Stripes serve to protect them. I think ScubaJess has a cool photo showing them both.

I find the Kincaid shrimp are usually facing downward on a slope, and look a lot like the daisy brittle stars, which are also often found nearby.

Candy stripe shrimp can be found beneath and on top of the snake lock anemones. They're very easy to miss because they're often more transparent or smaller than expected. Or on the back side of where your light is pointing :)

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Wed Sep 23, 2015 11:54 am
by Marek Sk
YellowEye wrote:Hi
I haven't heard of Shortcase Eualids. But yes, Kincaid shrimp are almost always nearby.
Thank you Eric Yellow Eye !

You caught my typo. It should have been Shortscale Eualid not Shortcase Eualid.
My apology to the critter to for misspelling its name too ;)

OK Here are my pictures zoomed in and distribution by site:
Until I had discussion with Drew Collins about 1 year ago these were my candy stripe candidates, they have red and white candy stripes but obviously the blue rings are missing.

Please note that I also made update today that these Shortscale Eualid candidates may actually end up being Threespine Shrimps.

Well, we live and learn all the time. I am sure Greg Jensen will comment on it and correct if it is not accurate.

Picture from Skyline wall:
PICT8891-candy-stripe-shrimp-shortscale-eualid-Skyline-zoom.jpg
Pictures from Titlow Tacoma:
PICT7749-ala-candy-stripes-shrimp-Tytlow-zoom.jpg
PICT7748-ala-candy-stripes-shrimp-Tytlow-zoom.jpg
PICT7717-ala-candy-stripes-shrimp-best-Tytlow-zoom.jpg
PICT0931-ala-candy-shrimp-Tytlow-zoom.jpg
PICT0928-ala-candy-shrimp--Tytlow-zoom.jpg
PICT5493-dragon-candy-shrimps-Tytlow-zoom.jpg
Here are multiple Shortscale Eualids or Threespine Shrimps and Coonstripe Shrimp to the right. This is captured also at Titlow.
PICT5492-dragon-candy-shrimps-Tytlow-zoom-multiple.jpg
Picture from Alki Cove 2:
PICT5015-candy-or-coonstripe-shrimp-horse-clam-Alki-C2-zoom.jpg
Picture from Redondo:
PICT8921-broken-back-or-candy-shrimp-Redondo-zoom.jpg
Picture from Rosario Head:
PICT6744-interesting-like-candy-striped-shrimp-interesting-tiny-red-sculpin-Rosarion-head-zoom.jpg

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2015 12:04 pm
by Greg Jensen
The third species in your photographs is the threespine shrimp, Heptacarpus tridens.

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2015 6:02 pm
by ScubaJess
Fantastic shrimp shots!! They always make me happy! :) glad you got so many varieties on film!

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2015 7:30 pm
by ScubaJess
Here's my shot of a Candy Stripe Shrimp guarding its snake lock anemone from a group of Kincaids.
It's always interesting to watch shrimp to see what they will do next! :)

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2015 5:01 pm
by nwscubamom
That is a GORGEOUS shot, Scubajess! So colorful!

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 10:56 am
by Echo
Yes They make me smile too!! The crimson anemone and candy-stripe shrimp just complement each other so well :)

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Sat Oct 31, 2015 1:41 pm
by Grant Novak
Perhaps you know this, Echo, but I believe the white bulge on the candy stripe in your photo is a parasitic copepod tucked under the shrimp's shell. They're not uncommon at all but they often go unnoticed/unidentified in photos.

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2015 9:21 am
by oldsalt
A retired marine biologist friend, aged 90 at the time, endured considerable discomfort on a research boat in the Sea of Cortez. When asked why he would put up with all of that, he answered, "I wanted to learn a lot of things I forgot!" I am at an age that I can relate to this. Thank you to Greg, Grant, Marek, et al Following these threads is a delight.
-Curt :thankyouyellow:

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2015 9:25 pm
by Greg Jensen
The parasite is a bopyrid isopod

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2015 10:10 pm
by Grant Novak
I stand corrected! And gladly so. Mr Jensen can correct me any time. Thanks for the clarification.

Re: Crimson Anemones, Candy Stripe & other 2 Shrimps / Eualids

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2015 7:58 am
by ScubaJess
Happy Saturday everyone!
Here are a few more candy shrimp shots. :pirate: :partydance: :joshsmith: :taco: